Wednesday, October 28, 2026

A PhD Is Not Just About Finding Something New. There Is More to It Than That.

 

Some little thoughts on originality, unexpected findings and lessons from my own PhD journey.

When I was doing my PhD, one phrase that kept appearing in the academic world was "original contribution to knowledge." If you are a PhD student, I am sure you have heard this phrase many times too. During proposal presentations, discussions with supervisors, research methodology classes and even viva preparation, this phrase seems to follow us everywhere.

But have you ever stopped for a moment and wondered what it actually means? Does it mean our research must discover something that nobody in the world has ever discovered before? Does it mean we need to come up with a completely new theory? Or perhaps find a research topic so unique that nobody has written about it?

Well, after completing my own PhD journey, I have come to appreciate that originality is not necessarily as complicated as we sometimes make it. In fact, I think we sometimes put too much pressure on ourselves, especially when trying to convince others that our research is something special.

One interesting thing I realised is that originality does not always appear exactly where we expect to find it. Sometimes, we begin our research with one idea about what our contribution might be, only to discover something rather different when we finally analyse our data and write our discussion chapter.

So, I thought I would share a few things I learned along the way, including a little plot twist from my own doctoral research. Nothing too academic or complicated, just some personal reflections that might be useful, especially if you are still trying to figure out what makes your PhD research original.

 Your PhD Doesn't Have to Change the World

Sometimes, I think we expect too much from ourselves. We want our research to be special, our topic to sound impressive and our findings to be something extraordinary. Nothing wrong with that, of course. After all, we are spending years working on something, so naturally we want it to mean something. But here is something I have learned. Your PhD does not have to change the whole world. It just needs to contribute something meaningful to what we already know.

For example, let's say many researchers have already studied leadership in organisations. Does that mean there is nothing left for us to investigate? Of course not. Perhaps previous researchers studied leadership in private companies, but we want to understand it within Malaysian public universities. Maybe they used qualitative interviews, while we want to examine relationships between variables through quantitative research. Or perhaps we want to explore how another factor might influence an existing relationship.

The general topic may be similar, but our approach and the insights we produce could be different. And that difference, if properly justified and supported by evidence, may become part of our original contribution. Of course, simply changing the research location or method does not automatically make a study original. What matters is whether the difference helps us understand something meaningful that previous research has not fully explained.

I think this is where we sometimes misunderstand the idea of originality. We assume that being original means everything about our research must be new, from the topic and theories to the research framework and findings. But research does not always work that way. Sometimes, originality comes from building on what others have already discovered, questioning an existing assumption or providing new evidence from a different context.

And interestingly, we may not fully recognise that contribution at the beginning of our research. Sometimes, it becomes clearer much later, especially when we start examining what our findings actually mean.

 Sometimes, Research Doesn't Give Us the Answer We Expected

This is probably the part I can relate to most through my own PhD experience. When we develop our research framework and hypotheses, we naturally have certain expectations. Based on previous studies and theories, we may expect a positive relationship between two variables or believe that a particular factor will influence another. We spend so much time developing our arguments from the literature, so naturally we hope that our findings will support what we have proposed.

But what happens when our data tell us something different? What if a relationship that we expected to be significant turns out to be statistically insignificant? Or what if the relationship exists, but behaves differently from what we initially expected? Does it mean our research has failed? Not necessarily. Sometimes, this is where the interesting part of research begins.

Let me share a little example from my own doctoral research. My study examined how ethical leadership and Islamic Work Ethics influence the development of learning organisations in Malaysian public universities, with psychological safety acting as a moderator. I collected data from 303 administrative staff across two public universities. Basically, I wanted to understand how leadership, work ethics and employees' sense of psychological safety might relate to an organisation's ability to continuously learn and improve.

Some findings were quite straightforward. Ethical leadership showed a significant positive relationship with learning organisations, which was consistent with what I expected. However, Islamic Work Ethics did not show a statistically significant direct relationship with learning organisations. To be honest, this finding was quite surprising, perhaps even a little alarming at first, especially when previous studies had suggested that Islamic Work Ethics could encourage positive workplace behaviour, knowledge sharing and innovation.

So, naturally, I started wondering why. Does this mean Islamic Work Ethics are not important in developing a learning organisation? Of course, we cannot simply make that conclusion. When I explored this further in my thesis discussion chapter, I realised there were several possible explanations. One interesting idea is that having good personal work ethics does not automatically mean an organisation will become a learning organisation.

Think about it. An employee may be honest, hardworking, responsible and committed to Islamic ethical values. But if the organisation does not have the right systems, supportive leadership or opportunities for knowledge sharing, those personal values may not necessarily translate into organisational learning. This explanation can be understood through the organisational learning framework by Crossan and colleagues (1999), which describes how learning moves from individuals to groups and eventually becomes part of organisational practices.

Another possible explanation is what we might call a normalisation effect. In a workplace where Islamic ethical values are already familiar and widely accepted, these principles may have become part of everyday working life. As a result, their influence on differences in organisational learning may be less noticeable. This is one possible interpretation that can be discussed using institutional theory, although my research did not directly test whether such a normalisation effect had occurred.

And then came another interesting finding, something I would call a little plot twist in my thesis.

I examined whether psychological safety, which generally refers to employees feeling safe to speak up, share ideas and take interpersonal risks, would influence the relationship between ethical leadership and learning organisations. Interestingly, the positive relationship between ethical leadership and learning organisations was stronger when psychological safety was low, rather than high.

At first, this may sound a little strange. We normally think that a psychologically safe working environment should support positive organisational outcomes. So why would ethical leadership show a stronger relationship with organisational learning when psychological safety was lower? One possible explanation is that ethical leadership may become particularly important in environments where employees feel less confident about speaking up or sharing their opinions. In such situations, leaders who demonstrate fairness, integrity and ethical behaviour may play an especially meaningful role in supporting organisational learning. Of course, this is a possible interpretation, not proof of why the relationship occurred.

What made these findings interesting to me was not simply that some hypotheses were unsupported or that the results were different from what I expected. It was the opportunity to look at the relationships from another perspective, explore possible explanations and connect the findings with existing theories. These discussions helped me see aspects of my research contribution that were not necessarily obvious when I first developed my proposal.

And that brings me to something I think postgraduate students should remember. Sometimes, the originality or novelty of our research becomes clearer only after we have collected the data, analysed the findings and started writing the discussion chapter.

Of course, unexpected findings do not automatically mean we have discovered something new. We still need to compare our results with previous research, consider the limitations of our study and support our interpretations with relevant theories and evidence. But we should not immediately see an unsupported hypothesis as a failure either. Sometimes, a finding that initially seems disappointing can open the door to a more interesting discussion.

Looking back, I think this was one of the most valuable lessons from my PhD journey. The findings that surprised me were also the ones that encouraged me to think more deeply about my research. And perhaps that is where part of our original contribution can emerge, not simply from discovering something completely new, but from offering a meaningful explanation or a different perspective on something we thought we already understood.

 What Makes Our Research Good Enough?

Another question worth thinking about is what actually makes research good enough, particularly when we want to publish our findings. We often focus so much on originality that we sometimes overlook other important aspects of research quality. An interesting finding may attract attention, but it does not automatically mean the study is strong enough to be published.

Think about the journal articles we read. A good research paper should clearly explain what the researcher is trying to investigate and why the study matters. The methodology should be appropriate, the data should be suitable and the analysis should be properly conducted. More importantly, the conclusions should reflect what the findings actually show, rather than what the researcher wishes they had shown.

Sounds quite straightforward, right? But achieving all these things requires effort. We cannot simply claim that our research makes an important contribution without showing how the evidence supports that claim. We also cannot draw conclusions that go beyond what our data can reasonably tell us. Even when our findings are interesting, weak methodology or unsupported interpretations can affect the credibility of the study.

I think this is especially important when discussing unexpected findings. It can be tempting to describe every surprising result as something novel or groundbreaking. But originality is not just about finding something different. We need to explain why the difference matters, how it relates to existing knowledge and what others might learn from it.

A strong thesis is not necessarily the one with the most complicated words, the most impressive diagrams or the longest discussion. Sometimes, what matters more is how clearly we explain what we have done, why we did it and what we found. Good research is not about making everything sound complicated. It is about presenting a convincing argument based on appropriate evidence.

And perhaps this is also how originality becomes meaningful. It is not enough to say that our findings are new or different. We need to help readers understand what those findings add to the existing body of knowledge.

A Little Thought Before I End

If there is one thing I have come to appreciate after completing my PhD, it is that originality and novelty do not always appear in the way we expect.

When we first prepare our research proposal, we are usually asked to identify our contribution to knowledge. We explain our research gaps, justify our framework and describe what makes our study different from previous research. And yes, these are important parts of planning a PhD. We need a clear direction and a reasonable justification before beginning our study.

But there is something interesting about research. The contribution we propose at the beginning may not be exactly the same as the contribution we finally recognise at the end.

Sometimes, after months or even years of working on our thesis, we discover that our findings do not fully support our original expectations. Perhaps a relationship we expected to be significant turns out otherwise. Perhaps a variable behaves differently from what previous studies suggested. Or perhaps the results reveal a pattern that we did not initially anticipate.

At that moment, it may feel disappointing. We may even start questioning whether something has gone wrong with our research. But before jumping to that conclusion, perhaps we should ask ourselves another question: What are these findings actually trying to tell us?

I think this is where the discussion chapter becomes particularly meaningful. It is not merely a place to repeat our results or explain which hypotheses were accepted or rejected. It is where we begin to make sense of our findings, connect them with existing knowledge, consider possible explanations and identify what our research may genuinely contribute.

I am not suggesting that every unexpected result is a new discovery. Sometimes, a surprising finding may simply reflect the limitations of our data, research design or measurement. But sometimes, when properly examined and supported, it may reveal something worth understanding further. And that possibility is what makes research interesting.

So, to my fellow postgraduate students, especially those still worrying about originality and novelty, perhaps we should not expect to have every answer at the proposal stage. We certainly need to know why our research is worth conducting, but we should also remain open to what the findings may eventually reveal.

Your original contribution may begin with a research gap, a different context or a new approach. But it may also become clearer through an unexpected finding, a thoughtful interpretation or an explanation that helps us see an existing issue differently.

For me, that was one of the meaningful experiences of completing my PhD. I began with certain research expectations, but some of the most interesting discussions emerged from results that did not turn out quite as I had imagined.

Perhaps originality is not always something we must fully discover before starting our PhD. Sometimes, it is something we gradually recognise through the research process, and only truly understand when we reach the end of our thesis.

After all, research is not about making the findings agree with what we already believe. It is about being willing to learn something from what we actually discover.

And sometimes, the answer we never expected may be the one that gives our research its most interesting contribution.

Just a little sharing from my own PhD journey. I certainly do not have all the answers, but I hope these reflections offer something useful to those who are still finding their way.

To everyone still working on your thesis, keep going. You may discover something meaningful in places you least expect.

Saturday, October 17, 2026

Feeling Stupid During Your PhD? Good. Maybe You're Doing Something Right.


Just some random thoughts about research, learning, and being okay with not knowing everything.

Let me share something interesting..

I recently came across an old article written by Martin A. Schwartz in 2008. The title really caught my attention.

“The Importance of Stupidity in Scientific Research.”

Stupidity? In research? Seriously? 

At first, the title sounds a bit funny. We always think researchers, especially PhD students, must be very clever people. They read thick books, write complicated papers, and talk about things that sometimes even Google cannot explain properly. Haha.

But this article made me think.

Maybe we have misunderstood what being a researcher really means.

You see, when we were in school, being smart usually meant knowing the correct answer.

Teacher asks a question. We answer correctly. We get good marks. Everybody happy.

But research is a different game.

In research, sometimes even your supervisor doesn't know the answer. Your professors may not know either. And that's perfectly normal.

Because if everybody already knows the answer, then what exactly are we researching?

Think about that for a while.

I remember during my own PhD journey, there were times when I felt completely lost.

Read one journal article, suddenly another five questions appeared.

Thought I understood something, then came another theory that made me confused again.

Sometimes I wondered, "Am I really doing a PhD, or am I just discovering how much I don't know?" 😂

And the funny thing is, the more we read, the more we realise how little we actually know.

Schwartz calls this productive stupidity.

Sounds strange, right?

But the meaning is actually beautiful.

It means we are brave enough to explore something we don't understand yet.

We ask questions. We make mistakes. We try again. Sometimes we get things wrong. Sometimes we spend days looking for an answer, only to discover that we were asking the wrong question from the beginning.

Frustrating? Of course lah.

But that's how learning happens.

One thing I really like about this article is the reminder that research is not about proving how clever we are.

It's about having the courage to admit that we don't know.

And believe me, saying "I don't know" is not always easy, especially when people expect you to know everything just because you are doing a PhD.

But actually, there is nothing wrong with not knowing.

The problem only starts when we pretend to know, or when we stop trying to learn.

Sometimes, our ego becomes a bigger obstacle than the research itself.

We are so afraid of looking stupid that we become afraid to ask questions.

And when we stop asking questions, we stop growing.

Simple as that.

Looking back at my own PhD journey, I realise something.

Perhaps those moments when I felt most confused were also the moments when I was learning the most.

Not because I suddenly became smarter overnight.

But because I slowly learned to be comfortable with uncertainty.

To accept that I don't need to have all the answers today.

I just need to keep searching.

And maybe that is one of the most valuable lessons a PhD can teach us.

Not how to become the smartest person in the room.

But how to remain curious, humble, and willing to learn, even when we think we already know enough.

So, to anyone currently doing research, especially my fellow PhD candidates, don't be too hard on yourself.

If today you feel lost, take a break.

If you don't understand something, ask.

If your research doesn't work, try another way.

And if you feel stupid sometimes, welcome to the club. Haha.

Just remember, feeling stupid doesn't automatically mean we are making progress. We still need to put in the effort, think carefully, and learn from our mistakes.

But don't let that feeling stop you.

Because sometimes, the most important discovery begins with three simple words.

"I don't know."

And perhaps the real beauty of education is not that we finally know everything.

It's that we become humble enough to realise we never will.

A PhD may give us the title of Doctor. But the real achievement is knowing that we will always remain students of life.

Just my two cents. 😊


Inspired by Martin A. Schwartz (2008), “The Importance of Stupidity in Scientific Research,” Journal of Cell Science, 121(11), 1771.

https://doi.org/10.1242/jcs.033340

Tuesday, October 6, 2026

Not Everyone Can Become a General, But Everyone Deserves a Meaningful Career


Sedikit renungan selepas hampir 30 tahun dalam tentera

Selepas hampir 30 tahun berkhidmat dalam tentera, ada banyak perkara yang hanya kita benar benar faham apabila kita keluar dan melihat semula organisasi dari luar. Semasa masih berkhidmat, kita bergerak mengikut sistem. Posting datang, kita pergi. Kursus datang, kita hadir. Diberi appointment, kita buat sebaik mungkin. Ada kawan yang naik pangkat lebih cepat, ada yang perlahan, ada yang akhirnya sampai ke pangkat tinggi dan ada juga yang berhenti pada satu tahap walaupun masih mempunyai bertahun tahun untuk berkhidmat.

Semakin saya fikirkan perkara ini, semakin saya merasakan bahawa pengurusan kerjaya dalam tentera sebenarnya jauh lebih besar daripada persoalan siapa naik pangkat dan siapa tidak. Ia adalah tentang bagaimana organisasi mengurus manusia yang telah dilatih dan dibentuknya selama 20 atau 30 tahun. Dalam bahasa pengurusan hari ini, kita bercakap tentang career development, talent management, human capital dan succession planning. Tetapi dalam bahasa mudah, persoalannya cuma satu. Adakah kita benar benar menggunakan orang kita sebaik mungkin?

Saya menulis ini bukan untuk mengatakan sistem kita semuanya salah. Jauh sekali. Sistem yang ada telah melahirkan ramai pegawai yang sangat baik dan profesional. Saya sendiri dibentuk oleh sistem tersebut. Tetapi selepas hampir tiga dekad melihat bagaimana kerjaya pegawai berkembang, saya fikir ada beberapa perkara yang wajar kita fikirkan semula.

Bila Sampai di Persimpangan

Dalam perjalanan kerjaya seorang pegawai, akan sampai satu tahap di mana laluan semakin sempit. Ini perkara biasa dalam mana mana organisasi berbentuk piramid. Tidak semua Kapten akan menjadi Mejar. Tidak semua Mejar akan menjadi Leftenan Kolonel. Tidak semua Leftenan Kolonel akan menjadi Kolonel, apatah lagi menjadi General.

Bagi generasi saya, salah satu persimpangan yang cukup besar ialah apabila seseorang pegawai sampai ke tahap Mejar dan pemilihan ke Maktab Turus Angkatan Tentera, atau MTAT, mula memainkan peranan penting dalam perjalanan kerjayanya. Mereka yang terpilih biasanya mempunyai laluan tertentu yang terbuka selepas itu. Mereka yang tidak terpilih pula mungkin melalui perjalanan yang berbeza.

Saya tidak melihat masalahnya pada hakikat bahawa bukan semua orang boleh pergi MTAT. Memang mustahil semua orang mendapat peluang yang sama. Persoalan yang lebih penting bagi saya ialah, apa yang kita lakukan kepada pegawai yang tidak melalui laluan itu?

Katakan seorang pegawai masih mempunyai 10 atau 15 tahun sebelum bersara. Dia mungkin tidak lagi berada dalam kelompok yang dirancang untuk laluan command tertentu. Tetapi adakah itu bermaksud pembangunan kerjayanya juga harus berhenti?

Dalam pengalaman saya, ada pegawai yang akhirnya berpusing pada appointment yang hampir sama. Sudah menjadi Ketua Kompeni, kemudian berpindah dan menjadi Ketua Kompeni lagi. Pergi batalion lain, buat perkara yang hampir sama lagi. Selepas beberapa kali, kita perlu bertanya, pengalaman baharu apa sebenarnya yang sedang kita bina pada pegawai tersebut?

Pemerhatian ini menarik apabila dibandingkan dengan kajian Husin et al. (2021) terhadap 1,686 pegawai TLDM. Kajian tersebut mendapati bahawa pusingan kerja yang kerap semata mata tidak semestinya mempercepatkan kenaikan pangkat. Sebaliknya, faktor seperti kekananan dan latihan yang mantap turut memainkan peranan dalam perkembangan kerjaya. Mereka turut menekankan bahawa pusingan kerja perlu dirancang dengan mengambil kira pangkat, pendidikan dan keperluan perjawatan.

Bagi saya, mesejnya cukup mudah.

Banyak posting tidak semestinya bermaksud banyak development.

Kadang kadang kita terlalu sibuk memindahkan manusia sehingga terlupa bertanya sama ada perpindahan itu sebenarnya sedang membangunkan manusia tersebut.

Apabila Peraturan Menjadi Kurang Jelas

Satu lagi perkara yang saya perhatikan sepanjang perkhidmatan ialah bagaimana pegawai memahami rules of the game dalam membina kerjaya.

Pada satu ketika dahulu, sekurang kurangnya pada persepsi ramai pegawai generasi saya, laluan itu kelihatan lebih mudah difahami. Untuk bergerak ke tahap tertentu, ada kursus yang perlu dilalui, appointment tertentu yang perlu dipegang dan pengalaman tertentu yang perlu dikumpulkan. Kita mungkin tidak suka keputusan yang dibuat, tetapi sekurang kurangnya kita memahami jalan yang perlu dilalui.

Apabila semakin banyak special cases dan pengecualian muncul, keadaan menjadi lebih complicated.

Perkara berkaitan MTAT ini juga pernah dibincangkan secara rasmi. Kementerian Pertahanan Malaysia (2026) dalam jawapan di Dewan Rakyat menjelaskan bahawa kursus MTAT bukan syarat wajib di bawah Akta Angkatan Tentera 1972 untuk kenaikan pangkat. Pertimbangan kenaikan pangkat turut mengambil kira faktor seperti kekosongan jawatan, tempoh perkhidmatan, kelayakan akademik, keperluan operasi, merit dan kompetensi. Pengecualian bersyarat juga boleh dipertimbangkan berdasarkan faktor tertentu seperti kepakaran teknikal, pengalaman medan dan keperluan kritikal perkhidmatan.

Saya boleh memahami rasional itu. Organisasi tentera tidak boleh terlalu rigid. Kadang kadang organisasi memang memerlukan seseorang dengan kepakaran tertentu dan sistem perlu mempunyai flexibility.

Tetapi flexibility juga mempunyai risikonya.

Apabila terlalu banyak keputusan kelihatan sebagai pengecualian kepada laluan yang selama ini difahami oleh anggota, orang di bawah mula tertanya tanya, what exactly are the rules?

Di sinilah timbul persepsi. Kita mula mendengar perkataan yang biasa didengar dalam banyak organisasi, "orang dia", "kabel", "networking" atau "my people".

Saya tidak mengatakan setiap special case berlaku kerana favouritism. Itu tuduhan yang terlalu besar dan tidak adil tanpa bukti. Ada kemungkinan pengecualian tertentu memang mempunyai justifikasi operasi atau organisasi yang kukuh.

Tetapi dalam pengurusan manusia, persepsi juga penting.

Sistem bukan sahaja perlu adil. Ia juga perlu dilihat sebagai adil.

Apabila seseorang pegawai memahami mengapa A dipilih dan B tidak dipilih, dia mungkin kecewa tetapi masih boleh menerima keputusan tersebut. Masalah bermula apabila dia langsung tidak memahami bagaimana keputusan itu dibuat.

Right Person, Wrong Place

Ini satu lagi perkara yang selalu bermain dalam fikiran saya.

Kita memilih seorang pegawai untuk mengikuti kursus tertentu, kadang kadang kursus yang sangat specialised dan mahal di luar negara. Katakan kita menghantar seseorang mengikuti kursus Electronic Warfare. Organisasi telah melaburkan wang, masa dan peluang kepada pegawai tersebut. Dia pulang dengan pengetahuan baharu, exposure baharu dan mungkin professional network yang sangat berguna.

Tetapi kemudian dia ditempatkan di appointment yang langsung tidak menggunakan kepakaran yang baru diperolehinya.

Mengapa?

Kadang kadang kerana kekosongan. Kadang kadang kerana keperluan organisasi. Dan berdasarkan apa yang saya lihat sendiri sepanjang perkhidmatan, preference terhadap tempat kerja dan hubungan sesama manusia juga kadang kadang boleh mempengaruhi perjalanan seseorang.

Di sinilah saya fikir kita perlu kembali kepada prinsip yang sangat simple, right person, right place, right time.

Latihan bukan hadiah kepada seseorang pegawai. Ia adalah investment organisasi.

Zainol et al. (2024) mengkaji 412 pemimpin dalam Kor Infantri Tentera Darat Malaysia dan mendapati bahawa aspek reka bentuk latihan, khususnya kandungan dan kaedah latihan, mempunyai hubungan yang signifikan dengan training transfer. Dalam bahasa mudah, nilai sebenar sesuatu latihan bukan hanya pada kursus yang telah dihadiri, tetapi sejauh mana ilmu dan kemahiran itu akhirnya boleh digunakan dalam pekerjaan.

Bagi saya ini common sense. Kalau kita membelanjakan wang dan masa membina sesuatu expertise, tetapi kemudian tidak meletakkan orang itu di tempat yang boleh menggunakan expertise tersebut, kita bukan sahaja mensia siakan potensi pegawai itu. Kita juga gagal mendapatkan pulangan terbaik daripada pelaburan organisasi.

Pegawai Staf Muda Bukan Masalah, Kurang Pengalaman Mungkin Masalah

Saya juga melihat satu kecenderungan lain. Ada pegawai yang masih agak muda dari segi pengalaman perkhidmatan sudah memegang appointment staf yang mempunyai pengaruh besar terhadap perancangan dan keputusan organisasi.

Saya mahu berhati hati di sini. Saya tidak percaya umur muda bermaksud seseorang tidak competent. Saya pernah bertemu ramai pegawai muda yang sangat pintar, cepat belajar dan mempunyai idea lebih segar daripada pegawai yang jauh lebih senior.

Jadi masalahnya bukan umur.

Masalahnya ialah experience dan institutional memory.

Lebih mencabar apabila seseorang hanya memegang appointment selama enam bulan atau tempoh yang terlalu singkat. Baru hendak memahami organisasi, stakeholders, sejarah sesuatu projek dan mengapa sesuatu keputusan dibuat beberapa tahun dahulu, sudah tiba masa untuk posting.

Pegawai baharu masuk. Dia pula datang dengan idea baharu. Beberapa bulan kemudian, orang lain datang pula.

Akhirnya banyak perkara sentiasa bermula, tetapi tidak banyak yang sempat matang.

Dalam pengurusan organisasi, ini membawa kita kepada persoalan organisational learning dan institutional memory. Organisasi bukan belajar melalui dokumen sahaja. Banyak pengetahuan sebenarnya berada dalam kepala manusia. Mengapa sesuatu keputusan dibuat, apa yang pernah gagal, siapa stakeholders utama, apa sensitiviti sesuatu isu dan apakah lessons learned yang mungkin tidak pernah tercatat dalam minit mesyuarat.

Apabila manusia bergerak terlalu cepat, sebahagian knowledge itu bergerak bersama mereka.

Saya fikir kita perlu bertanya bukan sahaja, "Siapa pegawai yang sesuai untuk appointment ini?" tetapi juga, "Berapa lama dia perlu berada di situ untuk benar benar memberi nilai?"

Tidak Semua Orang Boleh Naik, Tetapi Jangan Biarkan Mereka Berhenti Berkembang

Ini mungkin perkara yang paling dekat dengan hati saya.

Kita perlu menerima satu realiti. Struktur tentera adalah piramid. Tidak mungkin semua pegawai akan sampai ke pangkat tinggi. Jadi career management yang baik tidak boleh dibina atas assumption bahawa satu satunya bentuk kejayaan ialah promotion.

Bagaimana dengan pegawai yang kita sudah tahu mungkin tidak akan menjadi CO?

Adakah kerjayanya sudah selesai?

Saya fikir tidak.

Mungkin dia boleh menjadi instructor yang sangat baik. Mungkin dia mempunyai pengalaman operasi yang boleh digunakan untuk doctrine development. Mungkin dia sesuai dalam latihan, research, capability development, simulation, procurement, intelligence, liaison, safety atau bidang specialist yang lain.

Tetapi semua ini perlu dirancang.

Jangan biarkan seorang pegawai yang telah melakukan appointment sama berkali kali sekadar menunggu tarikh bersara.

Dalam kajian khusus mengenai ATM, Mohamed et al. (2023) mendapati bahawa career planning mempunyai hubungan yang signifikan dengan job satisfaction. Career development juga mempunyai hubungan yang signifikan dengan job satisfaction dan bertindak sebagai mediator dalam hubungan antara career planning dengan job satisfaction. Berdasarkan dapatan tersebut, penulis menekankan pentingnya menyelaraskan perancangan kerjaya dengan pembangunan kerjaya anggota.

Bagi saya, perkara ini sangat penting.

Manusia boleh menerima bahawa dia mungkin tidak akan menjadi General.

Tetapi lebih sukar untuk menerima perasaan bahawa organisasi sudah tidak tahu apa hendak dibuat dengannya.

Mungkin Kita Terlalu Mengurus Jawatan, Bukan Bakat

Di sinilah saya fikir kita perlu melihat semula peranan career management.

Cara paling mudah mengurus organisasi ialah melihat vacancy.

"Jawatan ini kosong bulan depan. Siapa kita hendak letak?"

Nama dicari. Posting dibuat. Vacancy selesai.

Administratively, problem solved.

Tetapi talent management sepatutnya bertanya soalan yang berbeza.

Siapa pegawai ini? Apa pengalaman yang dia sudah ada? Apa kepakaran yang organisasi telah laburkan kepadanya? Apa kekuatannya? Apa appointment yang dia perlukan selepas ini? Dan lima tahun dari sekarang, kita mahu dia menjadi apa?

Itulah beza antara managing vacancies dengan managing talent.

Menariknya, Tentera Darat Malaysia (2023) sendiri telah memberikan perhatian kepada talent management dalam penerbitan Sorotan Darat. Antara perkara yang dibincangkan ialah keperluan mengenal pasti lebih awal pegawai dan anggota yang mempunyai potensi untuk bergerak ke tahap lebih tinggi supaya pembangunan kerjaya mereka dapat dilaksanakan secara lebih tersusun.

Ini bermaksud idea tersebut sebenarnya bukan sesuatu yang asing kepada organisasi kita.

Pada saya, cabaran berikutnya ialah bagaimana kita menterjemahkan konsep itu daripada policy kepada kehidupan sebenar seorang pegawai.

Talent management tidak sepatutnya hanya mengenal pasti siapa yang berpotensi menjadi General suatu hari nanti. Ia juga sepatutnya menjawab persoalan, bagaimana kita mendapatkan nilai terbaik daripada mereka yang mungkin tidak akan sampai ke sana?

Kerana organisasi masih memerlukan Mejar yang bagus.

Kita masih memerlukan Leftenan Kolonel yang bagus.

Dan tidak semua orang perlu menjadi General untuk memberi sumbangan yang besar kepada tentera.

Succession Planning Bukan Sekadar Mencari Siapa Ganti Siapa

Satu lagi perkara yang saya fikir perlu diberikan perhatian ialah succession planning.

Kadang kadang kita melihat succession secara terlalu mudah. Si A akan keluar, siapa akan ganti A?

Pada saya itu lebih dekat kepada replacement planning. Belum tentu succession planning.

Succession planning sepatutnya bermula jauh lebih awal. Kita kenal pasti bakat, bangunkan mereka, beri pendidikan yang sesuai, beri exposure, rotate melalui appointment yang mempunyai tujuan, nilai performance mereka, lihat kelemahan yang perlu diperbaiki dan secara berperingkat menyediakan beberapa orang untuk tanggungjawab yang lebih besar.

Bukan seorang chosen one.

Kita bina satu pool.

Dalam konteks profesionalisme ATM, Stevenson (2019) turut membincangkan kepentingan sistem kerjaya yang adil, peluang pendidikan dan latihan, pemilihan berdasarkan pencapaian serta career progression and succession planning pada pelbagai peringkat dan pangkat dalam organisasi.

Saya sangat bersetuju dengan idea ini.

Succession planning yang baik bukan bermula apabila sebuah kerusi hendak kosong.

Ia mungkin bermula lima atau sepuluh tahun sebelum kerusi itu kosong.

Kalau kita hanya mencari pengganti apabila vacancy sudah muncul, mungkin kita sebenarnya tidak sedang mengurus succession. Kita cuma sedang mencari seseorang untuk mengisi kerusi.

Career Staff Sebenarnya Memegang Amanah yang Sangat Besar

Sebab itu saya selalu melihat mereka yang mengurus kerjaya anggota sebagai memegang tanggungjawab yang jauh lebih besar daripada sekadar mengeluarkan posting order.

Satu keputusan posting mungkin kelihatan kecil di atas kertas.

Tetapi bagi seseorang pegawai, keputusan itu mungkin menentukan lima tahun perjalanan hidupnya.

Ia boleh menentukan sama ada kepakarannya berkembang atau mati. Sama ada dia mendapat exposure yang diperlukan untuk appointment berikutnya. Sama ada dia masih melihat masa depan dalam organisasi atau mula menghitung tahun untuk bersara.

Career management therefore is not simply administration.

It is stewardship of human potential.

Sebab itu career staff juga perlu mempunyai keberanian untuk merancang kerjaya mereka yang tidak berada dalam fast track. Jangan hanya beri perhatian kepada mereka yang kita jangka akan pergi jauh.

Organisasi masih memerlukan Major dan Lieutenant Colonel yang bagus walaupun mereka tidak akan menjadi General.

Mereka masih mempunyai ilmu.

Mereka masih mempunyai pengalaman.

Dan mereka masih memakai uniform.

Malah mungkin kumpulan inilah yang mempunyai sesuatu yang sangat mahal untuk dibina, iaitu pengalaman selama 15, 20 atau 25 tahun.

Jangan Bina Hanya Seorang Pengganti, Bina Pilihan

Saya juga berpendapat ada satu bahaya apabila talent management terlalu awal menentukan siapa "orang yang akan pergi jauh".

Manusia berubah.

Pegawai yang kelihatan outstanding pada umur 30 tahun tidak semestinya menjadi pemimpin terbaik pada umur 50 tahun. Sebaliknya, seseorang yang mungkin tidak begitu menyerlah pada awal kerjayanya boleh berkembang dengan luar biasa apabila mendapat mentor, exposure dan appointment yang sesuai.

Sebab itu saya lebih selesa dengan konsep talent pool berbanding chosen person.

Berikan beberapa orang peluang untuk berkembang. Berikan mereka pengalaman yang berbeza. Kemudian biarkan performance, character, competence dan keperluan organisasi menentukan siapa yang paling sesuai apabila masanya tiba.

Ini juga membantu mengurangkan satu perkara yang sangat berbahaya dalam organisasi, iaitu persepsi bahawa seseorang sudah "dipilih" terlalu awal dan perjalanan selepas itu sekadar memenuhi syarat sebelum dia sampai ke kerusi yang telah disediakan.

Sama ada persepsi itu benar atau tidak, ia boleh merosakkan kepercayaan kepada sistem.

Akhirnya, Kita Sedang Mengurus Manusia

Selepas hampir 30 tahun memakai uniform, saya bertemu ramai pegawai yang hebat. Ada yang akhirnya sampai ke pangkat yang tinggi. Ada yang tidak. Ada yang sangat brilliant tetapi perjalanan kerjayanya tidak menjadi seperti yang diharapkan. Ada juga yang mungkin pada awalnya biasa biasa sahaja, tetapi apabila diberikan peluang yang betul, mereka berkembang menjadi pemimpin yang sangat baik.

Sebab itu saya semakin kurang percaya bahawa kita boleh menilai nilai seseorang hanya melalui pangkat terakhirnya.

Pangkat penting dalam organisasi tentera. Hierarchy penting. Command structure penting. Saya tidak mempertikaikan semua itu.

Tetapi talent management bertanya persoalan yang sedikit berbeza.

Adakah kita telah mendapatkan yang terbaik daripada setiap orang yang kita miliki?

Mungkin seseorang tidak sesuai menjadi CO. Fine. Cari tempat di mana dia boleh menjadi sangat berguna.

Mungkin seseorang tidak terpilih ke MTAT. Itu juga bukan penghujung kepada intellectual dan professional development beliau.

Mungkin seseorang tidak akan memakai pangkat Kolonel. Tetapi itu tidak bermaksud baki sepuluh tahun perkhidmatannya perlu menjadi sekadar menunggu pencen.

Dan mungkin seseorang memang sangat cemerlang dan berpotensi pergi jauh. Kalau begitu, bangunkan dia dengan betul. Jangan hanya berikan pangkat. Berikan pengalaman, cabaran, exposure dan tanggungjawab yang benar benar menyediakan dia untuk memimpin organisasi pada masa hadapan.

Not everyone can become a General. But everyone deserves a meaningful career.

Bagi saya, itulah cabaran sebenar pengurusan kerjaya.

Bukan sekadar menentukan siapa naik pangkat.

Tetapi memastikan manusia yang telah kita rekrut, latih dan bentuk selama berpuluh tahun terus mempunyai nilai, terus berkembang dan terus merasakan bahawa pengalaman mereka masih diperlukan sehingga hari terakhir mereka memakai uniform.

Kerana akhirnya, aset paling mahal sesebuah angkatan tentera mungkin bukan platform, senjata atau teknologi.

Ia adalah manusia yang mengambil masa puluhan tahun untuk kita bina.

Dan sesuatu yang mengambil masa begitu lama untuk dibina, sayang sekali kalau kita tidak menggunakannya dengan sebaik baiknya.

Rujukan

Husin, K. A., Shahiri, H., Abdullah Al-Hadi, A., & Mokhtar, A. (2021). Pengaruh pusingan kerja terhadap perkembangan kerjaya. Jurnal Ekonomi Malaysia, 55(3), 113–124. https://doi.org/10.17576/JEM-2021-5503-08

Kementerian Pertahanan Malaysia. (2026). Jawapan Dewan Rakyat berkaitan kenaikan pangkat pegawai Angkatan Tentera Malaysia. Parlimen Malaysia.

Mohamed, H. A. B., Mohd Som, H., Sahol Hamid, N., & Mohamad, M. H. (2023). Perceived career planning and job satisfaction in Malaysian Armed Forces: The role of career development as a mediator. International Journal of Management Studies, 30(2), 337–372. https://doi.org/10.32890/ijms2023.30.2.6

Stevenson, W. (2019). Upholding professionalism and caring for our defence and military personnel. The Journal of Defence and Security, 11(2). Malaysian Institute of Defence and Security (MiDAS).

Tentera Darat Malaysia. (2023). Sorotan Darat, 2(83). Tentera Darat Malaysia.

Zainol, N. A. M., Mohamed, H. A. B., & Yasin, R. (2024). Leadership development program: The correlation between training design and training transfer based on the Islamic perspective. International Journal of Management Studies, 31(1), 113–136. https://doi.org/10.32890/ijms2024.31.1.5